Claws: Cool, but expensive and not fantastic on the road in the rain.
Swampers (radial or otherwise): Awesome off-road, expect 10k miles on the highway and lots of trouble balancing them. If you are going to go for Swampers, do it right and get the TSL/SXs...
Goodyear MTRs: Excellent on dry rocks and everything off-road except mud (although the bigger sizes and 15" wheel models have better cleaning than the 16" wheel sizes), pretty good in the rain of the highway. Great mileage.
BF Goodrich MT KMs: Awesome off-road (I had 33x12.5s), great sidewall traction, excellent cleaning, ok in rain on the highway- but I had a few skids here and there... Good mileage- expect 50k miles on a set of well balanced MTs.
BF Goodrich All-Terrains: Simply the best all-terrain tire out there. Amazing in the snow. Crappy in mud. Excellent mileage- 50k miles easy. An excellent investment.
Pro-Comp tires: Unknown, but Justin had a set of the x-Terrains and so does Todd (Spidwre on CTJ). Ask them.
Cooper/etc: Get what you pay for, except Ron is running a set of some kind of new Firestone MTs that looked SICK and were reasonably priced.